You are hereA Peer Review How-to / Reply to comment
Reply to comment
|Title||A Peer Review How-to|
|Publication Type||Journal Article|
|Year of Publication||2008|
|Authors||Zucker, Robert S.|
|Keywords||Authorship , SCIENCE|
The article presents the author's suggestions for reviewers related to effective article reviewing. It is suggested that a reviewer should be prompt and thorough, and should avoid invective and sharp language. Furthermore, it is suggested that reviewers should take into consideration all of the journal's goals and requirements. It is stated that, reviewer should keep aside his scientific prejudices while reviewing. The author suggests not to reject a manuscript simply because its ideas are not original.